What Selling Candles at Craft Fairs Really Taught Us
Sep 18, 2026Our very first craft fair was a church basement in Holland, Michigan, and I still remember loading the car at 6 a.m. with a folding table we borrowed from my in-laws and about 40 candles we had poured on our kitchen table the week before. We had no signage, no card reader that worked, and a tablecloth that was two sizes too small. We sold nine candles that day. Nine. I drove home a little deflated, but Kayla looked at the receipts and said something I have never forgotten: "That is nine people who now have our candle burning in their house." She was right. Two of those nine became wholesale accounts within a year.
Craft fairs and farmers markets are one of the most underrated ways to grow a candle brand, and if you are figuring out how to start a candle business, they are one of the cheapest ways to get real feedback from real buyers. You learn more about your scents, your prices, and your packaging in one Saturday at a market than you do in a month of scrolling. Here is what three years and dozens of markets taught us at Garsnett Beacon.
Your booth is a storefront, so treat it like one
The single biggest jump in our sales came when we stopped thinking of the table as a table and started thinking of it as a tiny store. That means height, light, and a clear path for the eye. Flat tables full of candles all at one level get skipped. We started using crates, wooden risers, and a few small shelves to build levels so people could see everything from across the aisle. We added a simple banner with our name and a battery powered light or two for gloomy days.
Keep the front edge of your table clean and let people get close enough to smell. Smell is the whole game with candles. We learned to keep a "sniff set" of open testers up front, clearly marked, so nobody feels weird picking one up. If a customer can smell it, they are halfway to buying it.
Pricing at markets is different than you think
People assume you have to drop your prices at a craft fair. You do not. Market shoppers expect to pay full retail, and honestly they respect your work more when you price it with confidence. We sold our standard 8 ounce candles for the same price at markets that we charged online, usually in the 24 to 28 dollar range depending on the season. What moves the needle is not discounting, it is bundling.
Our best seller at every market became a "3 for" deal. Three candles for a set price that saved the customer a few dollars over buying them one at a time. It nudged our average sale from one candle to three without ever feeling like a discount. If you want to sanity check your numbers before you set a market price, run them through our candle pricing calculators so you know your real cost of goods and your margin on a bundle. Never price at a market without knowing that number cold.
Take the payment, always
That dead card reader on day one cost us real money. We watched two people walk away because we could only take cash. Do not let that be you. Get a Square reader or a simple tap to pay setup and test it at home before you go. Bring a phone battery pack, because a full day of transactions and photos will drain your phone by early afternoon. Keep a small float of cash and coins for the folks who still like paper. The easier you make it to pay, the more you sell. It really is that simple.
What actually sells at a market
After enough Saturdays you start to see patterns. A few things were true at almost every market we did:
- Familiar scents win. Vanilla, clean cotton, a good fall spice, a fresh citrus. Save your weird experimental blends for your online drops. At a market, people buy what they recognize.
- Seasonal sells fastest. In October we could not keep pumpkin and apple scents on the table. Lean into the season hard.
- Smaller sizes get impulse buys. A 4 ounce candle or a wax melt at a lower price point catches the person who is "just looking." That small sale often turns into a full size purchase online later.
- A gift bundle sells to the person shopping for someone else. Around the holidays, half our market buyers were not buying for themselves.
The real payoff comes after the market
Here is the part most makers miss. The money you make on market day is nice, but the real value is the list you build. We put a simple clipboard and a small sign on our table: leave your email, get 10 percent off your next order. We also had a little card in every bag with our website and our Instagram. Some of our most loyal customers today found us at a market three years ago and have reordered every season since.
If you do not have an easy way to capture those emails and follow up, that is the first system to build. A single market can hand you 20 to 40 new email addresses, and those people already smelled your product and handed you money. They are the warmest leads you will ever get. We talk about turning those contacts into repeat buyers all the time inside our free Candle Business PRO Facebook group, and it is a conversation worth having before your next event, not after.
Markets are also your wholesale pipeline
Do not overlook who else is walking the aisles. Shop owners, boutique buyers, and event planners go to craft fairs looking for makers. At our second year of markets we started keeping a small stack of simple line sheets under the table, and when someone said "do you sell wholesale," we handed one over on the spot. Several of our first brick and mortar accounts started exactly that way. If wholesale is a direction you want to grow, walk into every market ready for that conversation. Our Wholesale 101 guide breaks down how to set that up so you are not scrambling.
A quick pre-market checklist
Before every event, we run the same short list so nothing gets left in the garage:
- Table, risers, tablecloth that reaches the floor, and a banner with your name.
- Inventory counted and boxed, with your best sellers stocked deepest.
- Working card reader, phone battery pack, and a cash float.
- Tester candles up front and a "3 for" bundle sign.
- Email clipboard, business cards, and line sheets for wholesale asks.
- Bags, tissue, and a little something extra to make the handoff feel special.
If you want a fuller rundown of the supplies that keep a candle operation running smoothly, our supply checklist is a good place to start, and if you are still early in the journey, our 10 step guide to starting a candle business walks through the foundation before you ever set up a booth.
That first church basement felt like a flop. Nine candles. But every candle we make now, sold across 160 wholesale accounts and our own stores, traces back to the decision to keep showing up on Saturdays and getting our product into people's hands. Markets are not the whole business, but they are one of the best classrooms you will find. Pack the car, price with confidence, and go collect those emails. You can see where all that market experience led us over at the Garsnett Beacon store. It all started with a borrowed table.